Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (2024)

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (1)

by Susan Axelrod

Share this story

  • Share this on Facebook
  • Share this on Twitter
  • Share All sharing options

Share All sharing options for: Presenting Maine's Most IconicSandwiches

  • Pocket
  • Flipboard
  • Email

View as Map

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (2)

by Susan Axelrod

Share this story

  • Share this on Facebook
  • Share this on Twitter
  • Share All sharing options

Share All sharing options for: Presenting Maine's Most IconicSandwiches

  • Pocket
  • Flipboard
  • Email

Of course, the iconic Maine sandwich is the lobster roll, but that regional culinary treasure is not today's focus. Instead, we've rounded up a baker's dozen of other notable sandwiches, who, for 364 days a year must live in the lobster roll's long shadow. Right here, right now, is their long-awaited day in the sun. It's also a chance to pay tribute to Maine's many standout sandwich shops, including Hoss & Mary's Tasty Grub in Old Orchard Beach; Market Street Eats in Portland; Saco Island Deli in Saco; and yes, even (cue the outraged screaming) Amato's. Now, Maine is a big state, and despite help from friend-of-Eater and sandwich expert Joe Ricchio, we're sure we've missed a few. Please share your favorites in the comments.

Thank you to bloggers From Away and Map & Menu for sharing their photos.

Read More

Eater maps are curated by editors and aim to reflect a diversity of neighborhoods, cuisines, and prices. Learn more about our editorial process.

Blackened Fish Po'Boy - fans say the secret to this and other po'boys on the menu is the authentic bread.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (3)

Duck Confit Panini - This Portland icon represented Maine in Food Network magazine's "50 Sandwiches, 50 States." Chef Rob Evans press the duck confit with Napa cabbage slaw, cilantro and spicy mayo.

(207) 774-8080

(207) 774-8080

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (4)

The sign on this rural gem proclaims "Wicked Good Sandwiches" and they mean it. The reuben has achieved iconic status.

(207) 688-3029

(207) 688-3029

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (5)

Red Rooster - a huge menu here makes it hard to choose, but the combo of grilled chicken, bacon, provolone, spicy Thai mayo, red onion and pickles, perfectly wrapped, is the standout. Photo courtesy of Malcolm Bedell, From Away blog.

(207) 773-3135

(207) 773-3135

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (6)

Double Dragon Sub - Grilled pastrami, and steak with grilled onions, nacho cheese, russian dressing and cole slaw. Just one of the over-the-top creations at this OOB icon.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (7)

BBQ Beef Bahn Mi - noteworthy banh mi in ME? Yes, at Kim's, and at astonishingly low prices, about $3/sandwich.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (8)

Sign up for the newsletter Boomerang from Punch

The newsletter for the pro, aspiring pro or home enthusiast looking to get a BTS glimpse of drink culture.

Turkey Roo-Ben - "I will wear my undying devotion to this sandwich like a badge of honor." - Joe Ricchio.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (9)

The classic chicken salad sandwich is elevated at Clayton's with blue cheese and red grapes. Photo courtesy of Malcolm Bedell, From Away blog.

(207) 846-1117

(207) 846-1117

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (10)

The Original Italian - yes, it's a chain, but when it comes to icons, Amato's Italian is the one that set the standard for the state. Disagree? That's OK.

(207) 797-5514

(207) 797-5514

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (11)

Oyster Bun - the newest icon on the list, this small sandwich combines the pillowy-ness of a Chinese steamed bun with crispy fried oysters and pickled onions.

(207) 774-8538

(207) 774-8538

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (12)

Also featured in:

  • Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (13)

    14 Essential Restaurants in Portland, Maine
  • Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (14)

    The 18 Essential Maine Restaurants

The Bella Mortadella - Joe Ricchio's pick is a Monday only special with the original Italian bologna, fig jam and cheese. Photo courtesy of Map & Menu blog.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (15)

Whole Clam Roll - some gripe about the $15.95 price tag, but this is the state's gold standard in clam rolls. Don't like the bellies? Get the clam strip roll - just $8.95.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (16)

Fried Haddock sandwich - this is the "whole;" normal humans order the "half," which is still a lot of super fresh fish. Bet's brother catches the fish and she makes her own tartar and dill sauce. Opens for the season in May.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (17)

© 2024 Vox Media, Inc. All rights reserved.

Link copied to the clipboard.

Blackened Fish Po'Boy - fans say the secret to this and other po'boys on the menu is the authentic bread.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (18)

Duck Confit Panini - This Portland icon represented Maine in Food Network magazine's "50 Sandwiches, 50 States." Chef Rob Evans press the duck confit with Napa cabbage slaw, cilantro and spicy mayo.

(207) 774-8080

(207) 774-8080

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (19)

The sign on this rural gem proclaims "Wicked Good Sandwiches" and they mean it. The reuben has achieved iconic status.

(207) 688-3029

(207) 688-3029

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (20)

Red Rooster - a huge menu here makes it hard to choose, but the combo of grilled chicken, bacon, provolone, spicy Thai mayo, red onion and pickles, perfectly wrapped, is the standout. Photo courtesy of Malcolm Bedell, From Away blog.

(207) 773-3135

(207) 773-3135

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (21)

Double Dragon Sub - Grilled pastrami, and steak with grilled onions, nacho cheese, russian dressing and cole slaw. Just one of the over-the-top creations at this OOB icon.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (22)

BBQ Beef Bahn Mi - noteworthy banh mi in ME? Yes, at Kim's, and at astonishingly low prices, about $3/sandwich.

(207) 774-7165

(207) 774-7165

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (23)

Turkey Roo-Ben - "I will wear my undying devotion to this sandwich like a badge of honor." - Joe Ricchio.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (24)

The classic chicken salad sandwich is elevated at Clayton's with blue cheese and red grapes. Photo courtesy of Malcolm Bedell, From Away blog.

(207) 846-1117

(207) 846-1117

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (25)

The Original Italian - yes, it's a chain, but when it comes to icons, Amato's Italian is the one that set the standard for the state. Disagree? That's OK.

(207) 797-5514

(207) 797-5514

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (26)

Oyster Bun - the newest icon on the list, this small sandwich combines the pillowy-ness of a Chinese steamed bun with crispy fried oysters and pickled onions.

(207) 774-8538

(207) 774-8538

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (27)

The Bella Mortadella - Joe Ricchio's pick is a Monday only special with the original Italian bologna, fig jam and cheese. Photo courtesy of Map & Menu blog.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (28)

Whole Clam Roll - some gripe about the $15.95 price tag, but this is the state's gold standard in clam rolls. Don't like the bellies? Get the clam strip roll - just $8.95.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (29)

Fried Haddock sandwich - this is the "whole;" normal humans order the "half," which is still a lot of super fresh fish. Bet's brother catches the fish and she makes her own tartar and dill sauce. Opens for the season in May.

Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (30)
Presenting Maine's Most Iconic Sandwiches (2024)

FAQs

What sandwich is Maine famous for? ›

Of course, the iconic Maine sandwich is the lobster roll, but that regional culinary treasure is not today's focus. Instead, we've rounded up a baker's dozen of other notable sandwiches, who, for 364 days a year must live in the lobster roll's long shadow.

What is the signature sandwich of Maine? ›

The Maine Italian sandwich is prepared using a long bread roll or bun with meats such as ham along with American or provolone cheese, tomato, onion, green bell pepper, sliced dill pickles, Greek olives, olive oil or salad oil, salt and cracked black pepper. It is popular throughout Maine.

What is the number one sandwich in the United States? ›

What's America's favorite sandwich? More cheese, please. Grilled cheese, according to the data which revealed that 79 percent of people either "like" or "somewhat like" the ooey-gooey sandwich. That's no surprise, given that it's one of the most classic comfort foods.

What food is Maine known for? ›

The Best Meals in Maine

The state's natural bounty stretches from the sea — haddock, clams and the famed crustacean — inland to towering maples, blueberry bushes and potato fields. But don't worry, lobster lovers: We have plenty of tips for you, too.

What is a hoagie called in Maine? ›

A submarine sandwich, commonly known as a sub, hoagie (Philadelphia metropolitan area and Western Pennsylvania English), hero (New York City English), Italian (Maine English), grinder (New England English, Fulton County, NY), wedge (Westchester, NY), or a spuckie (Boston English) is a type of American cold or hot ...

What is a Maine Dagwood sandwich? ›

A Dagwood sandwich is a tall, multilayered sandwich made with a variety of meats, cheeses, and condiments. It is named after Dagwood Bumstead, a central character in the comic strip Blondie, who is frequently illustrated making enormous sandwiches.

What is the official pie of Maine? ›

In 2011, the Maine State Legislature designated blueberry pie, made with wild Maine Blueberries, as the official state dessert. Wild blueberries are harvested from late July to early September in Maine.

What is the name of the famous sandwich in New Orleans? ›

A muffaletta is a famous italian sandwich invented in New Orleans with cured meats (ham and salami), provolone cheese, olive dressing and great bread. The olive dressing sports chopped green and black olives with onions and olive oil and spices, and the bread is a round sesame-seed roll big enough for sharing.

What is the state sandwich of each state? ›

French Dip

What is the rarest sandwich? ›

Priced at a staggering $214, the Quintessential Grilled Cheese holds the Guinness World Record for being the most expensive sandwich in the world. The sandwich is made with rare Caciocavallo Podolico cheese, which is sourced from Southern Italy and made from the milk of the Podolica cow.

What is the oldest sandwich in history? ›

Rou jia mo – which translates to '”meat sandwich” – is a street snack that hails from the Shaanxi province in north-western China. It's said to be the world's oldest sandwich, dating back to the Zhou dynasty who ruled ancient China from 1046 BC.

Who is the king of sandwich? ›

Jeff Mauro, host of Sandwich King | Food Network.

What is the sandwich capital of the US? ›

No city obsesses over and identifies more with one sandwich than New Orleans does the po'boy. (The possible exception is Philadelphia, and frankly the cheesesteak is only that city's third-best sandwich, after the Italian hoagie and roast pork with broccoli rabe.)

What is the number one sandwich restaurant in the United States? ›

Subway. Stemming from humble beginnings as a small sandwich shop in coastal Connecticut, Subway has morphed into a global phenomenon that now boasts some 37,000 locations across more than 100 countries, with sandwich options spanning from buffalo chicken to meatball marinara to tuna.

What is sandwich Cape Cod known for? ›

Sandwich is one of the first towns greeting visitors to Cape Cod, and one of the last they see when leaving. While the rest of the world may know Sandwich for the distinctive glassware it produced in the 1800s, its most enduring legacy is as the oldest town on Cape Cod.

What sandwich is New England known for? ›

Maine and Connecticut: Lobster Roll

The well-known representative of New England, the lobster roll, is the best sandwich in two of the states in the region. Although there are many differences between the two, both are considered great sandwiches. Which one is better will remain a debate forever.

Is Maine known for lobster or crab? ›

Maine lobster is iconic, not only for its economic value but also for its delicious meat. While spiny lobsters caught in the southern Atlantic and Caribbean are only eaten for their tails, Main lobsters boast large meaty claws as well as delicate and delicious tails.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 5744

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.