The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (2024)

Holiday menu planning is in full swing, and if you're still looking for iconic dishes to add to your spread, why not opt for a recipe that you know will always go over well? What's guaranteed to be a hit, you ask. How about the recipes that we know home cooks in your state are searching for? From mains and sides to desserts and co*cktails, these recipes are the most searched-for recipes in your state, according to Betty Crocker data. Whether you need a new Christmas cookie or a delicious, cheesy side for your New Year's dinner, these recipes are certified winners.

01of 51

Alabama: Red Velvet Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (1)

Making red velvet cake from scratch is easier than you might think. Reviewers love this lightly cocoa-flavored cake and simple icing — but they also say it would taste divine with cream cheese frosting.

02of 51

Alaska: Russian Tea Cakes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (2)

Perfectly themed for the holiday season, these snowball cookies only require six ingredients. "Probably the easiest cookie you could make and they go quick in my house," says reviewer dieselgirl.

03of 51

Arizona: Hot Buttered Rum

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (3)

Mix up a big batch of this Hot Buttered Rum Batter so you can have the co*cktail at your fingertips all season long. When you're ready to use the mix, just add 1 ounce of rum to 1 tablespoon of batter and top with hot water.

04of 51

Arkansas: Lemon Icebox Pie

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (4)

No-bake desserts are always helpful, but especially so around the holidays. Whip up this five-ingredient pie in mere minutes then let it set for a few hours before serving. It's that simple.

05of 51

California: Streusel-Topped Pumpkin Pie

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (5)

This recipe is great for using a store-bought pie crust because the flavorful filling and streusel topping really do all the heavy lifting. Reviewers say you can use walnuts or pecans for the sweet and lightly spiced topping.

06of 51

Colorado: Peach Pie

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (6)

The double crust is the way to go for this peach pie. No need to go fancy with the pie crust design — a few simple slits will work, especially because the flavor will speak for itself.

07of 51

Connecticut: Apple Cider Doughnut Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (7)

What's not to love about this doughnut cake that's packed with apple flavor from three separate ingredients? You'll find apple cider, apple butter, and grated apples loaded inside this cake to really hit you over the head with apple flavor.

08of 51

Delaware: Strawberry Pretzel Salad

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (8)

With 4.8 stars and nearly 2,000 ratings, you know this three-layer "salad" is going to be good. The classic dessert salad starts with a layer of pretzels, followed by a layer of cream cheese and whipped cream, and gets finished off with a layer of strawberry Jell-O. If you haven't had this dessert yet, let this be your invitation to try it this year.

09of 51

Florida: Cobia with Lemon Caper Sauce

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (9)

While we don't have a cobia and lemon caper sauce recipe on our site, we do have this Chicken with Lemon-Caper Sauce recipe that's remarkably similar. Just cook up your cobia fish the way you normally would then top it with the lemon caper sauce from this recipe.

10of 51

Georgia: Key Lime Cupcakes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (10)

"This recipe is quick and easy to make. Contains a hint of lime with a moist cake and smooth cream cheese frosting. A great treat for everyone," says recipe creator Penelope.

11of 51

Hawaii: Better Than Sex Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (11)

This decadent 9x13-inch cake might just be better than anything. With devil's food cake, caramel, chocolate-covered toffee, and whipped cream, what's not to love?

12of 51

Idaho: Raspberry Pretzel Salad

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (12)

Just like the fan-favorite strawberry pretzel salad but with raspberry Jell-O and frozen raspberries instead. We don't have an actual recipe, but you can use this one and replace any strawberry-flavored ingredients with raspberry-flavored.

13of 51

Illinois: Almond Crescent Cookies

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (13)

"So simple and they turned out wonderful. I thought the amount of almond flavor was perfect. These are great if you need a last-minute dessert," according to reviewer Bullet.

14of 51

Indiana: Cheese Ball

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (14)

The humble cheese ball is such a great holiday appetizer because you can customize it however you like. You can add additional ingredients and even mold it into festive shapes — like wreaths, trees, or reindeer.

15of 51

Iowa: Black and Gold Salsa

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (15)

Whether you're supporting your Iowa Hawkeyes team or simply looking for a new appetizer, this corn and black bean salsa is the way to go. Everyone will love the fresh-tasting ingredients and you'll love just how simple it is to make!

16of 51

Kansas: Strawberry Poke Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (16)

All you need for this flavorful strawberry cake is a package of cake mix and five additional ingredients that you likely already have in your kitchen. Recipe creator Paula suggests making this cake a few days in advance because the longer it sits, the more moist it gets.

17of 51

Kentucky: Honey Bun Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (17)

If you like honey buns, then you'll love this Honey Bun Cake with its sweet, cinnamon flavors. This recipe uses a package of cake mix and all you have to do is doctor it up a little bit with some extra ingredients.

18of 51

Louisana: Bread Pudding with Bourbon Sauce

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (18)

This recipe lives up to its "best ever" name according to reviewers. With the sweet bourbon sauce and moist sourdough and brioche bread, this bread pudding is the perfect custardy consistency.

19of 51

Maine: Peanut Butter Frosting

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (19)

Peanut butter lovers won't be able to get enough of this lightly sweet frosting. It's perfect on top of brownies, cupcakes, cakes, or any other sweet you make this holiday season.

20of 51

Maryland: Sweet Potato Pie

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (20)

Sweet potato pie is a holiday classic — and for good reason too. "This was the best pie I have ever made. It was delicious. My family of 4 ate this pie in less than 2 days," says reviewer hubmonkey.

21of 51

Massachusetts: Spinach Cheese Squares

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (21)

Serve these simple spinach cheese squares at your holiday brunch, as an appetizer, or as a side dish during holiday dinner. They're so good you just might make them for all three courses.

22of 51

Michigan: Cheesy Potatoes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (22)

The holidays are all about comfort food, which is why we're adding this cheesy potato casserole to our menu. The delicious side dish uses just a few household ingredients — like canned soup, sour cream, frozen hashbrowns, and cornflake cereal.

23of 51

Minnesota: Rosettes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (23)

You do need a special tool to make this Scandinavian dessert, but acquiring a rosette iron is worth it for this dish. These fried dough rosettes are as delicious as they are beautiful!

24of 51

Mississippi: Lemon Icebox Pie

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (24)

"WOW!!! This has quickly become a holiday tradition in my family. Incredible taste and it couldn't be easier to make! An absolute winner," says home cook KPSOLOMON.

25of 51

Missouri: Gooey Butter Cookies

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (25)

If you love gooey butter cake (who doesn't?) then you need to try these cookies by the same name. The cookies are made with cake mix, so they have a similar texture to the gooey butter cake, but in a smaller size that you won't be able to stop eating.

Montana: Banana Bread

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (26)

Banana bread is great anytime, especially during the holidays. It's easy to make, only requires a few simple ingredients, and it's always a winner.

27of 51

Nebraska: Peanut Butter Blossoms

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (27)

Peanut butter and chocolate together are what dreams are made of. This four-ingredient cookie combines the best of peanut butter cookies and decadent chocolate in the perfect holiday dessert. Whether they're for your cookie exchange, Santa, or simply your family, we suggest you double the recipe because no one can get enough.

28of 51

Nevada: Chocoflan

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (28)

Chocoflan might be the most impressive cake you make all year. It starts with a layer of chocolate Bundt cake, topped with a layer of sweet, jiggly flan, and finished off with elegant caramel sauce. The cake is decadence in every bite.

29of 51

New Hampshire: Whoopie Pies

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (29)

Anyone with a sweet tooth will love these whoopie pies. They're two chocolate cake-like cookies filled with a vanilla frosting that make great after-dinner treats.

30of 51

New Jersey: Lemon Chicken Orzo Soup

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (30)

Stay warm this holiday season with a big bowl of orzo soup. This recipe is inspired by soup you'd find at Panera and is packed with hearty ingredients like chicken, spinach, carrots, celery, and orzo in a lemony broth.

31of 51

New Mexico: Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (31)

"This cast iron skillet version is so easy! Melted butter, brown sugar, and fruit form the base of this cake as it bakes in the oven — but once it's done and flipped, it turns into a delicious caramelized topping with cherry-studded pineapple rings," according to recipe creator Anne.

32of 51

New York: Ice Cream Cone Cakes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (32)

It may look like ice cream, but this adorable dessert is actually a cupcake inside a cone. Use yellow cake mix to make this recipe even easier and decorate your cones to look like your favorite ice cream flavor.

33of 51

North Carolina: Pineapple Lime Punch

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (33)

Kids and adults alike will love this non-alcoholic punch made with pineapple juice, apricot nectar, frozen limeade, and lemon-lime soda. "A well-balanced drink with just the right amount of fruity sweet, lightly carbonated tang that holds up well, even when it's been mixed with ice for a few hours," says reviewer Jay Kim.

34of 51

North Dakota: Ham and Scalloped Potatoes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (34)

This cheesy ham, pea, and potato side dish won't last long at your holiday dinner. The hearty scalloped potatoes are loaded with flavors from the cheesy, creamy sauce made with butter, parsley, garlic powder, onion powder, Cheddar, paprika, and pepper.

35of 51

Ohio: Buckeyes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (35)

You can't have an Ohio holiday without Buckeyes. These peanut butter balls are oh-so-simple to make and this recipe yields nearly four dozen — we promise, you'll need that many!

36of 51

Oklahoma: Texas Sheet Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (36)

Yes, Texas sheet cake in Oklahoma. But with a decadent, fudgy cake that's this easy, we understand why it's made all across the nation.

37of 51

Oregon: Hot Buttered Rum

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (37)

"This is one of the best hot buttered recipes I've tasted. If you enjoy sipping hot drinks, rum, whiskey, or brandy during cold winter months, do yourself a favor and try this. The mixes you buy in the stores don't hold a candle to this yummy, buttery drink recipe," raves reviewer Linda------.

38of 51

Pennsylvania: Apple Dumplings

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (38)

Apple dumplings can be a little tricky, but not these six-ingredient ones. They're made extra simple with refrigerated crescent roll dough and incredibly flavorful from a secret ingredient: Mountain Dew.

39of 51

Rhode Island: Italian Christmas Cookies

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (39)

These traditional Italian Christmas cookies are the perfect marriage between sugar cookies and shortbread cookies. They're melt-in-your-mouth tender, but not overly sweet.

40of 51

South Carolina: Catfish Stew

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (40)

"Very Good! Hot and spicy. We pre-cooked the catfish in lemon and pepper, and then simmered for about an hour on the stove until the potatoes were done. We ate the whole thing up," says reviewer nadine501.

41of 51

South Dakota: Ham and Scalloped Potatoes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (41)

"Scalloped potatoes and ham are baked in a creamy sauce with a mild cheese flavor. The recipe is really easy and affordable. I have never had anyone not like this dish," says recipe creator Gai Boyd.

42of 51

Tennessee: Sausage Balls

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (42)

Whether you serve these three-ingredient sausage balls for holiday brunch or as an appetizer at your get-together, they're sure to be a hit. All you need is pork sausage, biscuit mix, Cheddar, and 30 minutes to make these savory, rave-worthy snacks.

43of 51

Texas: Spicy Chex Party Mix

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (43)

Homemade Chex mix is a great snack to leave on every table at your holiday party. This spicy party mix has it all: Rice Chex, Wheat Chex, peanuts, pretzels, and Goldfish coated in a buffalo and ranch seasoning.

44of 51

Utah: Raspberry Pretzel Salad

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (44)

The salty, sweet combo of the pretzel Jell-O salad is a hit across many states. While we don't have a raspberry-specific recipe, this strawberry Jell-O salad has nearly 1,500 5-star reviews. All you have to do is replace the strawberries and strawberry Jell-O with raspberries and raspberry Jell-O.

45of 51

Vermont: Apple Crisp

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (45)

"This recipe is definitely worth the ratings it has! This is my first time making an apple crisp and it turned out AMAZING. I can't wait to bring this over to my next gathering," says one reviewer.

46of 51

Virginia: Gingerbread Cake with Lemon Glaze

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (46)

Gingerbread is one of the most beloved flavors of the holiday season. Let the delicious, spicy flavor shine with Chef John's gingerbread cake topped with a thin layer of zesty lemon glaze.

47of 51

Washington: Gingerbread Pancakes

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (47)

Treat yourself to these gingerbread pancakes one morning this holiday season. They only take 25 minutes to make and they're totally worth it for the spicy, sweet flavors.

48of 51

Washington D.C.: Southern Baked Macaroni and Cheese

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (48)

You only need five ingredients to make this grandma-approved baked mac and cheese. You may do a double take at the inclusion of yellow mustard, but reviewers love the out-of-the-box addition.

49of 51

West Virginia: Chex Party Mix

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (49)

No need to turn on your oven for this recipe — it's made entirely in the microwave! "Does it get better than Chex Mix? You seriously can't go wrong making this for any crowd or just for your family," says reviewer May McLaughlin Davis.

50of 51

Wisconsin: Peanut Squares

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (50)

These pound cakes coated in peanuts go by many names. The recipe on our site may be called a "Blarney stone," but that doesn't mean these tasty cakes can't be made during the winter holiday too!

51of 51

Wyoming: Two-Ingredient Pineapple Angel Food Cake

View Recipe

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (51)

Seriously, all you need for this cake is two ingredients: a package of angel food cake mix and a can of crushed pineapples. Just combine the two, bake, and top with whipped cream, fresh fruit, or even chocolate drizzle.

The Most Popular Holiday Recipe From Each U.S. State (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 5911

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.