How to avoid tough, rubbery, or even chewy chicken in your slow cooker - Beehive Meals (2024)

By Allyse Jackson

Whether you’re cooking at home, eating out at a fancy restaurant, or picking up something from the local drive-thru,there's a decent chance that you've run intotough, rubbery, or even chewy chicken at some point.Why does this happen and what can we do avoid it?

Generally speaking, there are two ways to cook food; dry heat or moist heat. Dry heat being more conventional through baking or grilling while moist heat employs water or water-based cooking liquid through a slow cooker (Crockpot) or pressure cooker (InstantPot).

Though our freezer meals are flexible enough for dry heat, the mealshave beenprimarily designed for slow cookers. This is so that the meats can be easily shredded and mixed with the sauce. Plus the “set it and forgot it” aspect of slow cooking is extremely convenient!

Slow cooking is great for certain cuts of meats that have a lot of connective tissue and that can be a little tougher (beef, pork, and chicken). Through the cooking process, the connective tissue turns to a gelatin allowing the meat to become easily shreddable or “fork tender.” In comparison to beef and pork, chicken breast has little connective tissue; which means the necessary cooking time isn’t as long to soften the connective tissue. In addition, chicken breast has less fat and can become dry (chewy or rubbery) if cooked for too long. Without moisture, the protein fibers in the chicken become elastic.

Included with each meal is a set of instructions to help you cook the meals. With that said, it is extremely important to understand your slow cooker as there are many variables (brand, size, age, etc.) that can influence the outcome of your meal.

Tips to avoidovercooking chicken:

1) Get to know your crockpot

If you haven’t, I recommend following our Instagram page and watching our stories as we try to frequently teach best practices for cooking our meals. In most stories, I mention that my Crockpot cooks hot so I adjust the cooking time down by 30-60 minutes depending on the meal.

It's worth taking the time to understand your slow cooker and adjust as needed. In a previous post, I give 5 Tips to Help get to know your Slow Cooker that would be worth the read.

2) Use the right Crockpot size

Aside from accidentally overcooking the meals, the most common reason we see for tough, rubbery, or overdone chicken is customers using a Crockpot that is far too big.

Each of our meals comes with a recommendedslow cooker size. This is important to note as cooking in a bigger or smallerslow cooker than recommended may influence cooking results.

Compare this to baking brownies, if the recipes calls for an 8x8 inch baking pan but you only have a 9x13 inch baking pan, you’ll need to adjust the cooking time as the extra surface space will cause the brownies to cook much more quickly than instructed.

This is the same with slow cookers. If the recipe calls for a 3-quart slow cooker but is cooked in a 6-quart slow cooker, you’ll need to adjust for the extra surface space or the meal may become overcooked.

3)Experiment with cooking times

Throughout the month, I would recommend paying close attentions to cooking times and how the meals turn out. Make adjustments as needed from meal to meal and in time, you’ll have the perfect sense of how long a meal should be cooked within your slow cooker.

4) Follow our social accountsfor more cooking tips and tricks

Follow us on Instagram at @beehivemealsand Facebook at facebook.com/beehivemeals towatch our stories for more tips and tricks on how to cook our meals. We are frequently showcasing different meals allowing customers to see how things turn out.

How to avoid tough, rubbery, or even chewy chicken in your slow cooker - Beehive Meals (2024)

FAQs

How to avoid tough, rubbery, or even chewy chicken in your slow cooker - Beehive Meals? ›

Aside from accidentally overcooking the meals, the most common reason we see for tough, rubbery, or overdone chicken is customers using a Crockpot that is far too big.

Why is my slow cooker chicken rubbery? ›

Aside from accidentally overcooking the meals, the most common reason we see for tough, rubbery, or overdone chicken is customers using a Crockpot that is far too big.

How do you keep chicken from getting tough in a Crockpot? ›

Don't Overcook the Chicken.

You can overcook chicken in a slow cooker. If the chicken is cooked too long, it will become dry and tough. Check your chicken for doneness early, especially if it is one of your first times making it.

Does chicken get more tender the longer you slow cook it? ›

That is why tough meats become “fork tender” in the slow cooker. Chicken breasts have very little connective tissue; that means they can be cooked quickly because the long cooking time needed to soften connective tissue isn't necessary. They also have little fat, which means they can become dry if cooked too long.

Why is my slow cooked chicken so chewy? ›

How can you cook boneless skinless chicken breasts in a slow cooker without them drying out and becoming rubbery/chewy? Chicken becomes rubbery/chewy when it's overcooked. So in general, including in a slow cooker, don't cook as long. There are lots of recipes online, they can give you a good place to start.

Is it better to cook chicken on high or low in the crockpot? ›

For optimal results, it's generally recommended to cook chicken on the low setting in a crockpot. This slower cooking method allows the chicken to become more tender and absorb flavors, resulting in a juicier and more flavorful dish compared to using the high setting.

Why is my chicken hard to shred in the crockpot? ›

The most important thing to know is that it's best to shred the chicken when it's still warm, preferably right after it's done cooking. As the chicken cools, the muscle fibers start to tighten up, which makes it a little tougher to shred.

How do you make chicken tender and not tough? ›

The best tenderizer though, is a salted yogurt marinade. The salt has the same effect as in a regular brine, but the lactic acid in the yogurt further tenderizes the meat. A 15-minute marinade with one cup of yogurt and one teaspoon of salt makes for the most tender chicken breasts imaginable.

Does cooking chicken in a slow cooker make it tough? ›

Does meat get more tender the longer you cook it in a slow cooker? Not if you're using a leaner cut in the slow cooker, like chicken breast or pork chops. To help keep these cuts moist, decrease the cook time to 2-4 hours.

Can you overcook chicken in a slow cooker? ›

The answer is yes, but you might not want to. Overcooked chicken tends to be dry and unappetizing. The slow cooker is a forgiving environment but even so, 8 hours or more is a long time for chicken to cook.

Why is my crockpot chicken rubbery? ›

Rubbery chicken is usually an indicator of overcooked chicken. The longer the chicken cooks, the more moisture it loses, and without moisture, the protein fibers become elastic, AKA rubbery.

How to make crockpot chicken not tough? ›

How to make perfect Slow Cooker Chicken Breast:
  1. Choose good quality chicken. ...
  2. Not too full or too empty: I use this 2.5 quart crockpot for, honestly? ...
  3. To sear or not to sear. ...
  4. Butter (my secret ingredient that makes all the difference). ...
  5. Don't overcook.
Apr 25, 2024

Why is my crockpot chicken mushy? ›

Most of the time mushy Crock Pot chicken is a result of cooking it too long. As you cook meat, the collagen breaks down into a gelatin. The longer chicken is cooked, the more this process happens. Do it right and you have perfectly tender meat; too long and your chicken becomes mushy.

What causes chicken to have a rubbery texture? ›

Protein, fat, and liquid are the three elements that make up chicken. As previously mentioned, the chicken loses moisture (and fat) as the cooking time increases, resulting in a rubbery texture.

Why is my crockpot roast rubbery? ›

There are several reasons why this could have happened even after so much cooking. First, your choice of a rump roast could be a factor since cuts from the hind quarter are very muscular and, since muscles are the most resistant to breaking, this cut is quite stubborn when it comes to becoming tender.

Is it okay to put raw chicken in a slow cooker? ›

Yes, you can put raw chicken in a slow cooker! Slow cookers and Crock-Pots are designed to cook raw meats. The direct heat from the pot, lengthy cooking time and steam created from the tightly covered container destroys bacteria, making slow cooking safe. You can put frozen chicken in a slow cooker, too!

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6125

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-12-23

Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469

Phone: +494124489301

Job: Marketing Representative

Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking

Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.